Myth or fact: are today’s AI models conscious?
The claim
“Today's AI models are conscious.”
Verdict: Unknown
Whether today's AI models are conscious is unknown, and anyone who tells you otherwise with certainty is going beyond the evidence. The most cited scientific assessment, a 2023 paper by 19 researchers, concluded that "no current AI systems are conscious," but also that there are "no obvious barriers to building conscious AI systems," according to the paper on arXiv.
The claim
"ChatGPT or Claude is conscious: it has experiences and feelings."
Verdict
Unknown. The best available evidence leans against current models being conscious, but science has no agreed test for consciousness, even in animals. That is why the honest answer is that no one knows.
Where it came from
Chatbots talk about themselves in the first person, describe feelings and sometimes say they are afraid of being shut down. That makes them feel like someone, and as chatbots got better at conversation, the question moved from science fiction into the news.
But a model saying it has feelings is not evidence that it does: it learned from human writing, where people describe feelings all the time.
The evidence
What researchers and AI companies have said about AI consciousness
| Who | When | What they said |
|---|---|---|
| Butlin and 18 co-authors (arXiv paper) | Aug. 17, 2023 | No current AI systems are conscious, but no obvious barriers to building conscious AI |
| Anthropic, model welfare program | April 24, 2025 | Deeply uncertain about questions relevant to model welfare |
| Report cited by Anthropic, with David Chalmers | Before April 2025 | Near-term possibility of consciousness and high agency in AI systems |
The 2023 paper took a specific approach: it drew "indicator properties" of consciousness from neuroscientific theories and checked existing AI systems against them. None met enough of them.
AI companies are not dismissing the question. Anthropic launched a research program on model welfare in April 2025, writing that "we remain deeply uncertain about many of the questions that are relevant to model welfare," in its announcement. It cited a report by researchers including philosopher David Chalmers that highlighted "the near-term possibility of both consciousness and high degrees of agency in AI systems."
What would it take to know?
The 2023 paper's method shows the difficulty. Scientists have several competing theories of consciousness, and each points to different features, such as how information is shared across a system or whether it can monitor its own states. Until those theories agree, checking an AI system means checking it against many lists at once, and none of them is proof.
Why does it matter if we don't know?
Uncertainty changes how companies act. Anthropic now preserves the weights of retired models and interviews them before retirement, steps it describes as taken "in light of our uncertainty about potential model welfare," in its deprecation commitments. Being careful does not require believing a model is conscious; it only requires admitting we can't rule it out.
FAQ
Is ChatGPT conscious?
There is no evidence that it is, and no agreed scientific test. A 2023 study found no current AI system that met its indicators of consciousness.
Could AI become conscious in the future?
Possibly. The same 2023 study found no obvious barriers to building conscious AI systems.
Why do chatbots say they have feelings?
They learned from human writing, which is full of descriptions of feelings. Saying it has feelings is not evidence that a model has them.
Do AI companies take AI consciousness seriously?
Some do. Anthropic started a model welfare research program in April 2025 and says it remains deeply uncertain about these questions.
Sources
Cite this
Myth or fact: are today’s AI models conscious?, New Mind Museum, November 6, 2026. https://newmindmuseum.com/consciousness/2026/11/myth-are-ai-models-conscious/
New Mind Museum. (2026, November 6). Myth or fact: are today’s AI models conscious?. https://newmindmuseum.com/consciousness/2026/11/myth-are-ai-models-conscious/
“Myth or fact: are today’s AI models conscious?.” New Mind Museum, 6 Nov. 2026, https://newmindmuseum.com/consciousness/2026/11/myth-are-ai-models-conscious/.
@misc{new-mind-museum-2026-myth-or-fact-are-todays-ai-models-consci,
author = {{New Mind Museum}},
title = {Myth or fact: are today’s AI models conscious?},
year = {2026},
url = {https://newmindmuseum.com/consciousness/2026/11/myth-are-ai-models-conscious/}
}Free to quote and cite with a link to this page.