Can AI be conscious? The main theories, side by side
No one can say yet, and the researchers who have looked hardest agree on that much. A 2023 report by 19 authors, including Patrick Butlin and Robert Long, concludes that no current AI system is conscious. It also sees no obvious technical barriers to building one that meets its tests. Philosopher David Chalmers rates today's large language models as somewhat unlikely to be conscious.
How do researchers even approach the question?
There is no blood test for consciousness, so researchers work from theories. Three papers show three different ways in. One checks AI systems against ideas from brain science. One lists what stands in the way of language models. One asks what to do while the answer is unknown. They don't compete, since they answer different questions, so the table below puts them next to each other.
Three reports on AI consciousness compared
| Report | Date on arXiv | Question it asks | View on current AI |
|---|
Butlin and colleagues: does an AI have the signs?
What it says. The report, posted on arXiv in August 2023, draws on several prominent scientific theories of consciousness. It names recurrent processing theory, global workspace theory, higher-order theories, predictive processing and attention schema theory. From them the authors derive "indicator properties," described in computational terms so that an AI system can be checked for them.
Evidence. The authors used the indicators to assess several recent AI systems. They also discuss how future systems might implement them.
Verdict. Their analysis suggests no current AI system is conscious. It also suggests nothing obvious blocks engineers from building systems that satisfy the indicators.
Limit. The approach is only as good as the theories behind it. The arXiv page shows the report as a preprint with no journal listed, and it dates from August 2023, so it says nothing about systems built since.
Chalmers: what stands in the way of language models?
What it says. Chalmers gave this talk as an invited lecture at NeurIPS on November 28, 2022. It appeared in Boston Review on August 9, 2023, and the arXiv version was last revised in August 2024. He sets out the strongest reasons for and against the idea that a large language model could be conscious.
Evidence. Working from mainstream assumptions in the science of consciousness, he finds significant obstacles in current models. He names three: no recurrent processing, no global workspace and no unified agency.
Verdict. He judges it somewhat unlikely that current models are conscious. But he says these obstacles could be overcome in the next decade or so, and that successors to language models may be conscious in the not-too-distant future.
Limit. His conclusion depends on those mainstream assumptions. It is one philosopher's weighing of the arguments, not a measurement of any model.
Long and colleagues: what if we can't be sure?
What it says. This report, posted on arXiv on November 4, 2024, has 10 authors, including Butlin and Chalmers. It argues there is a realistic possibility that some AI systems will be conscious or robustly agentic in the near future. If so, AI welfare and moral patienthood, meaning AI systems with their own interests, would be a near-term issue.
Evidence. The report is an argument about uncertainty, not a test of any system. It recommends three early steps for AI companies and others: acknowledge that AI welfare is an important and difficult issue, start assessing systems for evidence of consciousness and robust agency, and prepare policies for treating them with appropriate moral concern.
Verdict. The authors say plainly that they are not arguing that AI systems definitely are or will be conscious. They warn of two risks: harming systems that matter morally, or caring for systems that do not.
Limit. It tells you how to decide under uncertainty. It doesn't tell you which systems, if any, deserve concern.
Where do the three agree and differ?
They agree on the present. None claims that a current system is conscious. They also agree on the future: each treats conscious AI as a live possibility, not science fiction.
They differ in emphasis. Butlin and colleagues stress that no obvious technical barrier exists. Chalmers stresses the obstacles, then expects some to fall. Long and colleagues set the metaphysics aside and ask what companies should do now.
The theories overlap, too. Recurrent processing and a global workspace appear in Butlin's list of theories and in Chalmers's list of missing pieces.
What the research doesn't tell us
None of these papers shows what consciousness is, and none shows that a machine has experience. They rest on theories that scientists still debate. They also cover only the systems that existed when each was written. For a look at how one AI lab handles the question, see whether Claude is conscious.
How should you read a claim about AI consciousness?
Ask which question the claim answers. Whether a system is conscious now gets a cautious no from these three reports. Whether a future system could be gets a serious maybe. What to do about it gets a call to prepare. Be wary of anyone who answers all three with the same confidence.
Ask your AI
Ask your AI which indicators of consciousness it thinks it lacks, and how anyone could check. Then compare its answer with Chalmers's three obstacles: recurrent processing, a global workspace and unified agency.
FAQ
Is any AI conscious today?
The 2023 report by Butlin, Long and colleagues suggests no current AI system is conscious. Chalmers says it is somewhat unlikely that current large language models are.
Which theories of consciousness are used to test AI?
Butlin and colleagues survey recurrent processing theory, global workspace theory, higher-order theories, predictive processing and attention schema theory, and derive indicator properties from them.
What is AI welfare?
It is the question of whether AI systems could have their own interests and moral significance. A November 2024 report argues that is a realistic near-term possibility and that companies should start taking it seriously.
Sources
Cite this
Can AI be conscious? The main theories, side by side, New Mind Museum, November 18, 2026. https://newmindmuseum.com/consciousness/2026/11/can-ai-be-conscious-theories-compared/
New Mind Museum. (2026, November 18). Can AI be conscious? The main theories, side by side. https://newmindmuseum.com/consciousness/2026/11/can-ai-be-conscious-theories-compared/
“Can AI be conscious? The main theories, side by side.” New Mind Museum, 18 Nov. 2026, https://newmindmuseum.com/consciousness/2026/11/can-ai-be-conscious-theories-compared/.
@misc{new-mind-museum-2026-can-ai-be-conscious-the-main-theories-si,
author = {{New Mind Museum}},
title = {Can AI be conscious? The main theories, side by side},
year = {2026},
url = {https://newmindmuseum.com/consciousness/2026/11/can-ai-be-conscious-theories-compared/}
}Free to quote and cite with a link to this page.